Central Pizzeria & Restaurant in Fort Erie

This will probably be one of the strangest reviews ever. I’m not even sure why I’m doing this, maybe I’m just bored.Let me start by saying I haven’t eaten @ Central Pizzeria in over 40 years. Yes, you read that right. I graduated high school in 1979 and CP was always one of our go-to places. I highly doubt it’s the same owner after all these years but back in my day, the pizza was unbelievably delicious. Maybe this is why they’ve been around for so long. Their plain slice was to die for. Pardon me for taking a trip down memory lane, as I said, I must be bored. Enjoy the pizza, hopefully it’s just as delicious as I remember. 🍕😃

Walked in late one night with some friends, and there were already two other people in the restaurant when we walked in. I'm not sure what the issue was with the two guests already in the store, but my friends and I were just trying to get a late night snack. The appropriate thing to do would have been to kindly inform us that the restaurant was closed, but what we got instead was a beast of a security guard barking at us to get out. I'll admit that my adrenaline got the best of me and I told the guy to "chill the F out." With that being said, you're running a business in a tight-knit community and that is not how you interact with guests. The only reason that your restaurant is getting 1 star is because 0 stars isn't an option.

Stole $5,000 from a customer, still have not given it back. They should be held accountable for their actions and give it back. Such disrespect to steal from a customer.

Sorry. Had to try but plain pie on a Tuesday night was cold (not hot) and doughy. It happens; but when I called they argued with me and said it wasn't cold. That's the quickest way to get me to post this review about a $14 cold plain pie. Won't be ordering again anytime soon. Good luck.

So I go down to this restaurant that I placed an order for a large pie I get there to see someone pull out a burnt pizza guy comes to the door I told him I ordered a pizza he says I did not so what that wasn’t my burnt pizza you pulled out of the oven excellent customer service

Pizza is dry, on more than one occasion. Appears as if they leave pies out for extended time. Dough is very thick!

Quality is a little bit rip off and any tops prices, I'm not happy with that. 3 dollars each any tops to add. and foods wasnt great for this price and old foods. Garlic breads price is a little bit rip off! I wasted of money on garlic breads, it wasnt great at all and dry cheese!. This place wasnt high and best to serve and crusty and flat tasty, expired foods. It's not for me. Some foods are great.

open late, more of a bar than a restaurant and I don't like hearing the occasional altercations at the bar. unless you specifically want pizza, walk 50 yards west to Manions for a better experience

Very friendly atmosphere & the pizza great... I will definitely go back!!!!

My wife and I frequent this place at least once a month and they never disappoint. Food is always amazing. We love their piazza, wings and salads.

Update your web so it doesn’t say you’re still open when you’re not!!!!!

Whether getting just a slice or a whole pie, the service is always fast and friendly and the pizza is always delicious!

Just a nice pizza place. Other items available as well.

Nice place

First time order, pizza, sub, and a fettuccini Alfredo... all were very happy! Will be happy to try again!

This has become our go-to place for pizza, hot sandwiches, etc. Addicted to the fried calamari!

The best in the Ville

Great pizza that hasn't changed in years (over 30 years). Consistently great service and just a nice local pizza joint. Meat lovers is amazing

Great tasting fresh pizza and great service!!! The waitress at the front was my favorite she was so helpful and friendly. I Will go again.😃

Taste marinara sauce. Krispy pizza. Please is very clean. Smile Staff

First time there - two couples - all four dishes ordered were very good - service was reasonable - I try to eat gnocchi whenever I see them on the menu - I have to say these were cooked to perfection and served with a delightful bolognes sauce -

The service there was excellent... I felt like a regular, when in fact it was my first time actually indulged in that specific bar... Very nice...

Great pizza and wings !

Seriously good food!

What I didn't like were the coed showers but everything else was pretty good.

The best pizza place

I’m a Pizza lover and this has been theeeeee worst pizza I have ever had in my life. . No Flavor whatsoever. Pizza tough. Their grated cheese taste like chemicals. Frozen pizza is way better. Should have went to Alfonso’s.

Just So Nice It's Good

Always great pizza, prices and friendly workers.

Pizza was good, but not real hot.

i used to go here because i liked their garlic knots but i just found two dead flies on them because they were probably sitting all day uncovered. that's absolutely disgusting

Good quality pizza with a charming little bar in the back. Great place for a quick bite to eat with a drink or to hang out later into the evening, with a bumping night life.

I decided to revisit Central Pizzeria to check-in and compare the quality from two years ago to now. I'm happy to say that the quality has improved. The plain slice is still pretty average, but the margherita slice was tremendous. The sauce was rich and flavorful and the fresh basil was a pleasant addition. The base was browned perfectly and the crust was crisp and crunchy. Overall, this is a decent spot!

First time I was here ..I ordered for to go ...food was delicious.

Nice people comfortable environment good food and good beer

Amazing food, amazing service, etc.

Went to a birthday party and had a great time. Had no idea that their was a bar in the back. Very chill place great vibes great people

Great pizza. A lot people go across the street, but central's pizza is so much better. Staff is always nice too.

Great little neighborhood place to eat and meet. We go to the small bar in the back. Great wait staff. Cheese steak sandwich was delicious. Homey atmosphere.

The owner PAT is a rip off artist. Changes prices every time you go in and then gets caught and acts like he forgets. Plus the pizza is cray. The crust tastes like cardboard. The sauce is good that's about it.

Good pizza. Nice bar.

I recently went to Central Pizza and ordered a “gourmet” pie with “the works” on it. The pizza tasted OK, but it did not appear to be made fresh. Instead, it seemed like it was a sausage and pepperoni pie that they just dumped a bunch of peppers, mushrooms and onions on. I would not go there again.

Best Pizza in The Ville

Best pizzeria in town. Great atmosphere, friendly staff, great food, great drinks, cheap prices. The specials are always an amazing deal. The owner is a great guy, he always remembers me and greets me with a smile. I've come here for multiple days straight because i don't like to cook and I never get tired of the food and people over at Central.

their lasagna was a HUGE disappointment, paid $17 for a sloppy grease covered meal. yuck

I love there 🍕!!

Loved Central since I was a child❤

We ordered a plain pie again today the crust was very soggy not crispy like they used to make it. This is the second time we get soggy pizza. Garlic knots I did not taste the garlic at all, they were stale and tasted old. Will not be ordering from here again.

Best pizza in town!

If you love Jersey pizza this place is for you. Always a classic with a great location and clean facilities